I’ve owned a dozen different brands of sheet cake pans. In every size and brand you can imagine. And after seven years in the cake decorating business, I’ve come to know which ones I love and consider the best sheet cake pans.
With all the pans I’ve bought, they’ve varied from super cheap pans from the dollar store to really expensive, heavy duty pans.
I own at least one of every popular brand of pans on the market – and I have an opinion on them. I won’t go into all of that today, but I’m hoping my trial and error with pans will help you buy the best ones the first time around.
The ones I love are not the most expensive (by a long shot), but they’re the best quality I’ve found and they’re a great value.
Now I know when people talk sheet cake pans, they may not all be talking about the same thing so I’m going to cover a couple of different kinds. Let’s get started…
The Best Sheet Cake Pans
For an actual sheet cake that’s typically decorated and sold in grocery stores and by cake shops alike, you’re talking about a 9x13x2 inch pan (or larger). The pans are usually 2 inches deep (also sold in 3 inch depth). I don’t use the terms half sheet, quarter sheet, full sheet, etc. because I’ve found that these sizes aren’t always uniform in the baking community.
I’m sure there’s a correct size for a “quarter sheet cake” but there’s some conflicting information out there, so I just say 9×13 or 10×15 or whatever. Then I give my clients the number of servings for whichever size I’m talking about and go from there.
Traditional Sheet Cake Pans
Anyway, for traditional “sheet cakes”, I love Parrish Magic Line Pans. Actually, this is my favorite brand for all traditional cake pans (round, square and sheet pans)! They’re quality pans that bake evenly and beautifully. Magic Line pans also hold up for the long haul and do not warp even after thousands of runs through my oven.
Best of all, Magic Line pans also have super sharp corners for sheet and square cakes and I love that feature! With our recent move, I’ve had to split cake work between the new house and the old one. I didn’t have all of my sheet pans in one place to take pics for this post, so I only have the one size pictured.
But I actually have these three sizes:
A couple of times I’ve needed an odd size in between those and I’ll just slide two together… and have a 13×18 or 20×15. That’s what I did for this huge bank order a few years ago…
I baked 4 (yes, four) 12×18 sheet cakes, then I stacked them 2 layers deep and pushed them together for a huge 24×18 cake that was over 4″ tall. That cake was a beast.
Nordic Ware Commercial Sheet Pans
Okay… aside from traditional cake pans, these Nordic pans are also called sheet pans. These are not usually used for tiered or layer cakes – but rather for things like jelly roll cakes or petit fours. The most popular thing I’ve used them for on the blog is petit fours – and that is a super popular recipe for me. Here is part of my collection:
I also use these pans to bake cookies, bars, bread, biscuits, roasting veggies, broiling bacon, and a million other things. They are seriously good for so many things!! I have 20+ of them and I still can’t ever have enough!
Oooh, you can also get lids for them which is thebomb.com. I love to store unfrosted cupcakes on them with a lid to keep them fresh until I’m ready to decorate.
The Nordic Ware sheet pans are diffrent from the Magic Line pans in that they don’t have straight up and down sides or sharp corners and they’re only about 1 inch deep vs. 2-3 inches. Nordic Ware Sheet pans also come in quarter sheet, half sheet, and full sheet sizes, but I’m going to give you the dimensions in inches.
Because I’m a rebel like that 😉
Below are the four sizes of Nordic Ware Sheet Pans I have:
- 13×18 pans (this is the size I have the most of – they’re SO awesome!) or with lids here
- 10×13 pans (also called quarter sheet pans) or 10×13 pans with lids
- 21×15 pans – this is a huge pan and I have 3 of them, but I don’t use them as often as the others
- 10×6 mini sheet pans
Although I don’t use them for anything related to cake decorating, I had to share the fourth size and tell you a little story behind them.
Months and months ago Richy took me out to eat on a date. We tried a new restuarant and they served our appetizer (loaded fries) on these itty-bitty sheet pans.
Who knew there were sheet pans that tiny and why had I never seen them? I’m a sucker for all things tiny and was completely obsessed with these pans. I might have even asked the server if I could slip one in my purse 😉 For the record, she laughed and said no, so I fought my urge to steal one… haha.
But my super thoughtful husband caught on to how much I loved the pans so he came home and ordered me some for my upcoming birthday. Ya’ll… this man knows me oh-so-well. Those little pans were maybe one of my favorite gifts ever.
Anyway, if you like itty-bitty things, you must get you some of those pans. I can’t tell you what to use them for, but they’re just so stinkin’ cute.
Since I bought them, we’ve mostly used them to heat things in the oven. For instance, I hate microwaving leftover pizza. I much prefer to warm it in the oven and get the crust all crispy again. So that sheet is the perfect size for a big slice of pizza.
Anywho… I got off track there. Sorry.
Alphabet Cake Pan
The only other sheet cake pan I want to mention is this Alphabet Pan. It’s really not a “sheet pan” in the traditional sense, but it’s worth a mention. I love this pan!
The Alphabet Pan an incredibly versatile pan that you can use for letters and numbers. But additionally, you can use it to make odd-sized rectangles, like for this tractor cake. I have a full tutorial with pics here.
And that’s that – the best sheet cake pans in all forms (that I use). I’d recommend having at least a couple of these sizes and varieties on hand for your orders. Unless of course you choose to not do sheet cakes… then ignore this whole post. Haha!
Did I forget anything? I’d love to hear it if you have thoughts on other varieties of sheet cake pans. And if you have different “favorites”, leave me a comment and tell me which ones you prefer!
Happy Caking!
Rose
Wife to Richy. Mommy to 6 kids. Homeschool Teacher. Jesus Freak. Good Books. Baker. Friend. Loves to Laugh. Photographer. Chocolate Addict. Mathematician. Pink. Diet Dr. Pepper-aholic. Cook. Flip-Flops. Ponytails. Loud Music. Writer. Budget-er. Chocolate Milk. Pillow Hog. Late-night TV & Junk Food.
I also have a 7″ x 11″ sheet pan from Wilton. I use it for smaller orders when the 9″ x 13″ is too any servings.
I love your blog, excellent advice! And yes those Tiny sheet pans are adorable! Ok I gotta buy them. Thank you for your advice and inspiration.
I’m off to shop for pans.
Denise
I too have a mini pan. Mine is 8×12 and has a metal rack. I can’t remember where I got it since it has been mine for many years. I can’t think of a time I have used it for cakes–but yes, for small batches of biscuits, a square pancake project (on top of the griddle), and with the rack, for small roasts and pork tenderloin. I’ve used it as a tray for small things in the kitchen many times.
Oh boy can I relate to that Bank of Franklin cake. But I have say, i have you beat, I had to do not one but TWO that size cakes for a very odd baby shower FOR my FIRST real commission as a cake decorator after finishing Wilton classes which my mother got me in to. I had done lots for family but not others. But you know mothers. I told her later that was payback for when a kid I was ALWAYS volunteering her to do things. Here is the deal. My mother on staff at a nursing home. The head nurse was having her FIRST child, age 40. She was person who felt any fuss made over her was appropriate. She had married a year before. The nursing staff had the “shower” (another name for “suck up to me big time or pay) They had it at our family retirement community in the large community bldg. I got to observe this first hand. When baby was announced it was decided to have the “shower” at work. (She wanted gifts from ALL 3 shifts of staff) Therefore the cake to last for three shifts (plus some patients will managed some of course). Its a big place. I ended up making TWO cakes of what you show PLUS added on the top a one layer cake of Wilton’s baby carriage cake. The cakes were SO heavy my dad had to make cake boards from plywood which I covered in the stuff Wilton sold for that at the time. It took two STRONG people to carry each cake. Thank heavens my folks have a GMC Suburban to haul them. I had the big community room a disaster working in it. I lost track of the buttercream made that day. My mom and I had baked the cakes the day before at her house where she has 3 ovens and access to 2 more on the farm. This was almost 10 years ago. My mom FINALLY retired from the home in the fall. That head nurse was fired about 4 years ago. My mom had only been working on call (age 75). Last week she said they called and asked her to come back. She said no. I will NEVER forget that cake experience. Talk about a baptism by fire. I was never so glad to see the back of any cake in my life. I don’t know about anyone else but when I finish a large cake (usually tiered) I run, not walk to a hot, soapy, glorious bubble bath. I always feel so gross and so covered in sugar I can’t stand it. Honestly, I don’t care if I EVER do a cake that large again. Yours seems a better memory than mine.
Love your everything you share!
But…I have to say Rose…Way too many ads on there you can hardly read something and you have to click off so you can finish reading… and then they pop right back up!
Completely understand that it helps pay for your website .
But when there’s like 10 and you’re just talking about pains that’s kind of crazy… just saying
Hi Wendy, I’m sorry for your poor experience. I normally don’t have so many ads – I’m reaching out to my ad manager this morning to see what might have changed or what’s going on. Thanks for being a reader!
You have NO idea how much You have just helped me! You’re the best
Do you have a basic recipe for each size pan? I have trouble adjusting for size and getting done centers. Advice. Thx so much.
I don’t Letecia. I use this Wilton chart to get a good estimate for the amount of batter for each pan. Some recipes require a little more or less, but learning that only comes with practice!
Hi Rose, Thank you for posting so much and answering question for bakers just starting to get customers. It is so helpful most will not help others. I do have a question about the large cake you did. I was on short notice to get a half sheet pan its ordered but, really not sure it will get here in time you said you put 2 cakes together after baking 4. Could you put 2 9 X 13 X2 to make almost the same size half sheet cake. I have the 9 X 13 X 2 pans and if it would get me out of a jam. I wouldn’t mind at all doing 4 of those I just thought how would you slide them together side by side without your buttercream sliding where they come together maybe be a silly question but, I do want it to come out very nice. Did you just place them side by side then decorate or seal the edges with buttercream or something? Thank you so much for your help and your champagne cake was beautiful. And thanks for the tip about the gold sheets.
I didn’t have any trouble with them sliding or separating. I used a thin later of buttercream where the cakes joined, then made sure to have a thicker layer on the outside edges.
Thank you Rose for your quick response. The pan came, now if I can just get it decorated so they will like it. Never did a cake this big it has a half sheet cake on the bottom and a smaller rectangle on top mostly for decorations.
I have been struggling for over a year on how to charge for cakes and have given the best answer! Thank you so much and I look forward to more advice God Bless